Cupcake Mondays – Stuff It!

My gym bag was literally the epitome of Sometimes Healthy Living this morning:

A Sometimes Healthy Gym Bag: Running Shoes, Cupcakes and...Frosting?

Yep, that would be homemade cupcakes (and a can of buttercream frosting) right next to my gym shoes. I toyed with the idea of carrying yet another bag, but I didn’t feel like enduring numerous eye rolls on the subway yet again as I smacked people unknowingly with my 50 million bags. Besides, the cupcakes fit so perfectly in the nook of my gym bag. And, promise they were covered very tightly.

Please don’t think I would ever  infuse my cupcakes with gym shoe flavor. That would be taking healthy living wayyy too far. And it would also be pretty gross. My coworkers would no longer L-U-V me.

Cupcake Mondays

I’m an avid reader of Carrots n’ Cake, as I’m sure most of you are. One of my favorite themes on Tina’s blog is Cookie Friday. Many times on her blog, she’ll share a cookie recipe and also enjoy one herself as a celebration for a week’s worth of hard work. As she writes, it’s a “mini celebration with a sweet reward.”

I always liked the thinking behind this theme post. We all celebrate in our own ways at the end of the week, whether it’s a glass of wine with friends a happy hour,  a marathon of Jersey Shore/Bachelor Pad, a giant bowl of self-serve frozen yogurt topped with weird things like gummy bears and frosted animal crackers or of course, a cookie.

Some celebrate with cookies, some celebrate with vino, some celebrate with frozen yogurt that weighs 8 pounds.

But, what about the beginning of the week? Who jumps of bed bright and early Monday morning morning with a smile on her face and says, “I can’t wait to work 50 hours this week, try to squeeze in some workouts, fight through hoards of pushy people on my commute, oh, and of course, try to sleep?”

I wake up every morning with a giant smile on my face and a...fedora?

Yeah, that doesn’t happen.

So, last night, I came up with what I thought was a brilliant idea: Cupcake Mondays! In my opinion, nothing on this earth has the ability to bring smiles to faces like a cupcake. Cakes are delicious. Cookies are ooey, gooey, warm and scrumptious. Ice cream is the perfect summer treat. BUT, nothing has the power to bring laughter and cheer out of even the biggest Monday hater like a moist, flavor-packed adorable cupcake.

Sunday Night Baking – Adventures in Stuffing

As you all know, I often try out my latest healthified cupcake recipes on my guinea pigs coworkers. It’s a win-win celebration for all. I get to try out my weird ideas on my willing subjects friends, and they get to enjoy a mid-day snack that’s not quite as sinful as a regular cupcake. Plus, it’s free food. Who doesn’t like free food?

I decided the healthified part is essential to Cupcake Monday’s success. After all, no one wants to start their week off on an UNhealthy foot, so with my healthified treats, they can start it out in a Sometimes Healthy way 😉

So, with the Monday Cupcake Cheer theory in mind, I set out to do a little baking last night. I could have stuck with the ever-popular chocolate cake + apple sauce duo, but then I thought to myself, “Gee Jamie, at some point, you really need to think outside of the cake box.”

Gotta think outside that cake box...but what should I do?

No no, I didn’t do anything too drastic – like attempt to make them from scratch. That’s way too far out of the box for a girl that wakes up at 5:30 AM Monday mornings.

Instead, I felt inspired by back-to back episodes of Cupcake Wars to stuff my cupcakes.

Inspired yes. Ambitious, not-so-much.

I could have read up online about how to properly “stuff one’s cupcake” and the proper cupcake fillings, but a) I find that to be a huge timesuck and b) I always worry I’ll accidentally copy someone’s brilliant idea.

So, instead, I sought creative consultation from my best friend, Emily.

She suggested pudding for a Boston Cream Pie cupcake. I took it a step further and added in some crushed pretzels that I needed to quickly get rid of before devouring the whole bag.

Vanilla puddings + pretzels...this could get interesting.

And then I spotted some of that delicious Marshmallow Fluff (which helped me get through Irene) at the grocery store. So, I figured I might as well stuff half of my cupcakes with some of that gooey deliciousness.

This sh*** is good. trust.

There wasn’t much method to my madness.

Place batter in tins, coat with yummy filling...

I filled 12 tins halfway, plopped in about a tablespoon of filling and topped them off with the rest of the cupcake mix.

Now you see the filling, now you don't.

In to the oven they went at 350 degrees for about 35 minutes.

Don't judge a book/cupcake by its cover...please.

When all was said and done, I had 12 ugly cupcakes that I imagined would get even uglier on the commute into work. BUT, I tasted the choco-marshmallow cake and decided it definitely passed the taste test. The filling aspect kind of disappeared as the marshmallow melted into the chocolate, but it gave it kind of a yummy s’mores kind of taste. Just what I wanted.

A Frosting Back-Up Plan

I’ll just admit it. I didn’t have the utmost confidence in these cupcakes. The fillings just didn’t look quite right, they weren’t the most attractive things on the block, and even with my trusty gym bag carrying approach, they were slightly smushed.

So, just in case, I brought a can of frosting, figuring those who didn’t like the actual cupcake could just “elevate” the taste with a bit of frosting and sprinkles. Everything’s better with frosting and sprinkles – even healthified cupcakes gone awry.

Awkward, healthified cupcakes...backed up by frosting and lots of candy.

I also filled the candy dish to provide an alternative for the cupcakes…clearly these weren’t exactly what I envisioned last night.

There was some sort of filling action goin' on...

Needless to say, I did have my usual happy customers.

I always have at least ONE happy customer

Good ol’ Anjelica. She always convinces me that my baking tastes better than it actually does ;-).

So, the hours ticked by and before I knew it, it was  7:30 and 5 cupcakes remained. uh oh. 5/11 – not a good sign. Usually cupcakes are gone at 60 seconds at my workplace.

Around 7:45, I got desperate. I just can’t bear to see my cupcakes uneaten. So, I wandered around to see which of the late night warriors hadn’t eaten dinner yet. “They’re hungry – they’ll eat anything,” I thought to myself.

And I was right. A small crew gathered at my desk, eager to polish off the remainders from Cupcake Monday.

They were so hungry, they said they'd eat ANYTHING...

Amidst the laughter and gossip, I noticed they sure were adding a lot of frosting to their cupcakes.

NO NO it's not a frosting bar...there are CUPCAKES!

Apparently, working late at the office also eliminates people’s inherent ability to lie to your face. Here was the feedback on today’s cupcakes:

  • “Jame – I love you…but, I don’t know if I like this cupcake
  • “If it has lots of frosting, it’s good.”
  • “It crumbles in a…weird way.
  • “What exactly is inside? Why is it mushy?”
  • “It wasn’t that bad…”
  • “The frosting’s REALLY good.”

So, the general consensus on today’s cupcakes: good enough to eat with a giant mound of frosting. 

However, I’m not one to be easily defeated. I consulted with the our office’s resident baker, aka the one that makes the best-tasting cake pops I’ve ever had in my life

These cake pops are the best around...

.She doesn’t healthify, but her stuff tastes good. I mean REAL good. She always wanted to start a bakery, and she probably should.

Anyway, she informed me that when I want to put fillings in my cupcakes, I should just remove the center after they’re baked and fill ‘er up. That way the filling won’t melt into my cupcakes and make it gooey and crumbly. However, she said, if I want to put things like candy bars or pretzels in my cupcakes, THEN I can use the method from above.

Good thing she’s around. Lesson learned: next time I’ll do a little research before I go outside of the cake box.

But like I always say, “You can’t home runs every time.” I still achieved my goal of bringing smiles and laughter on a Monday at work through cupcakes…even if it was mostly laughter AT my awkward cupcakes ;-). I’ll make up for it next Monday.

Off to bed – physical therapy bright and early! COMEBACK here I come!

Putting my desire for injury recovery before the nagging desire to see who won the Bachelor Pad. I deserve a medal already.


How do you stuff your cupcakes?

What’s your fave cupcake filling?

What’s the funniest comment you’ve ever received on your baked goods gone bad?

23 Thoughts on “Cupcake Mondays – Stuff It!

  1. HIlarious comments from the co-workers! Tastefully polite ;). I have never made a stuffed cupcake, and honestly am not sure I’ve ever even baked a cupcake! Sad! I can make some mean muffins though.

  2. Ha ha ha – you are a bigger woman than I am. I wouldn’t have even attempted to alter the cupcake at all. I have a hard enough time following the instructions on the box. :)

    My favorite comment was “If it has lots of frosting, it’s good.” So funny!
    Hey – at least they didn’t smell like gym shoes!

  3. 1- um, fantastic idea. this could revolutionize monday mornings.
    2- they look DELICIOUS.
    3- i love the cupcakes and gym clothes bag – you’ve gotta have a balance!
    4- the fedora pic is so cute!

  4. It is bullshit that you don’t work at my office. Seriously.

  5. Michelle on 13 September, 2011 at 10:33 am said:

    You know, this post just made my Tuesday… I do wish I still worked with you!

  6. This is too funny! I love it!

  7. Great post as usual lovely lady!!
    Your co-workers are great, at least they told you what could be improved in a rather nice way :) Anything is salvageable with frosting if you ask me!

  8. It’s lunchtime, and now all I want are cupcakes. What’s on tap for next Monday? And uh, where’s your office? Maybe I could, you know, accidentally “bump into” your cubicle on my lunch break? Hahaha.

  9. hahahah you are hilarious. Can you please save me some cupcakes next time? i’ll walk to your office to get them!! lol

  10. I wish you worked at my office. Cupcakes would make Mondays way more bearable. And your smiling cheerful face too :) Haha, I think the funniest comments are something like “wow, this, um, tastes really healthy..” hehe.

    I pretty much enjoy anything stuffed into a cupcake as filling. vanilla pudding, peanut butter creme, nom nom nom

  11. There’s NOTHING better than coming to work on Monday (half asleep), and seeing tin foil surprises on Jamie’s desk. She is super sweet and always lets me dig in for breakfast. :) We ALL know how lucky we are to have Jamie!

  12. Sign me up to work with you on Mondays!! I would love you forever. Plus I normally enjoy the flavor or healthified cupcakes because I do the same to mine. When I fill mine I use a gun thing that stabs into the center and expels the good into the middle.

  13. You are adorable and I would love it if you came and worked at my job so I can too enjoy yummy treats on those dreaded Mondays! haha

  14. You took my advice!! Sorry they weren’t any good :)

  15. Pingback: Cupcake Monday: Hoppin’ on the Pumpkin Train | The Sometimes Healthy Living Blog

  16. Pingback: Cupcake Monday: Yellow Cake Mix Two Ways | The Sometimes Healthy Living Blog

  17. Pingback: Chocolate Chip Donut Monday, Packing and Pumpkins | The Sometimes Healthy Living Blog

  18. Pingback: Crumbs Cupcake Monday and Healthy Switches | The Sometimes Healthy Living Blog

  19. Pingback: Cupcake Monday, Bachelorette Parties and Bitter Beer Face | The Sometimes Healthy Living Blog

  20. Pingback: Sometimes Healthy, Usually Cupcakes | The Sometimes Healthy Living Blog

  21. Pingback: Birthday Cake Pancakes, Chocolate Chip Pancake Cupcakes AND Snowstorms | The Sometimes Healthy Living Blog

  22. Pingback: Kitchen Adventures: Healthified Bacon French Toast Cupcakes | The Sometimes Healthy Living Blog

Post Navigation